Like what you see?

Enter your e-mail to receive daily updates from

Delivered by FeedBurner

$100 000 000 sites 2012 olympics 2020 2020 Tokyo Olympics 360 3D 3-D 3-D camera 3D movie 3-D printing 3DFusion 3vr 9/11 90 911 aairport security aartificial intelligence AAugmented Reality accelerometer ads aging AI Air Force air movements airplane airport airport security AIRprint Allison Leotta alzheimers Analog analytics analyzer Android anybots API app Apple application apps AR archeology architecture archived video Arduino art artifical skin artificial intelligence astronauts Atlantis ATMs attack attacks ATV auction audio recognition augemented reality Augmented Reality aurasma Austin Australia Author Autism avalanche AVATAR avatars AXON backscatter x-rays baking Balloons Bandit bank security banking security banned substances Barajas Airport BarSpace baseball batteries Beatles beepers Bermuda bicultural Big Bang Theory Bigelow bilingual bin laden binoculars biofuel biology biomarkers biometric Biometric Bouncer Biometrics biomimcry bionic bioterrorism birthdate blackberry blood alcohol level body body language bombs bones Border border security Boston Marathon BP brain Brain control Brains Branson breath bribe bristol lab Britian Brown bubbli bullying butterfly c3 technologies California Cambridge camera Cameras cancer cancer cells Cape Town Stadium car car bomb car bombing carbon monoxide cargo Carnegie Mellon carrier iq cars casino security catapult CBP CBS News poll ccomputer vision CCTV CCTV surveillance Cell Phone Cell Phone. machine learning CERN CES Chaochao Lu charging chatroulette chicken children China Christian Isaac Peñaloza Sanchez Christian Kandlbauer Christie's Chu Cirque Du Soleil clear Clicck cloud cloud computing clouds Coca-Cola coilgun comfort computer computer security computer vision conferening congress conservation construction consumer electronics show Consumer Physics contact cookie cool roofs coriander Cornell cows credit cards crime crowdsource crowdsourcing curvilinear cyber security dance dancing DARPA Dartmouth Data security data storage defense spending delivery denmark design Detriot DHS diagnose diary DICE diet digital advertising displays digital sensors DigitalGlobe directions disaster relief discovery diseases displair DIY dna dna 11 Dodo Pizza Dogs dolphins domestic violence domodedovo airport Dot dreams drinking drone drones dslr Dubai Duke University Dynamic Shape Display e3 earth earth day earthquake Easter eggs e-books ecobotIII Egypt election electric vehicles Electronic Privacy Information Center EMILY emotions endeavor energy engineering Engkey English environmental protection agency Eugene Goostman europe Expect Labs experts explosive materials eye eye movements eyeball eye-tracking camera fabrics face detection face recognition Facebook faces Facial detection Facial Recognition farm Fast Company Fast Food FBI fcc fda felony Fence fFacebook fFacial Recognition FIFA FIFA World Cup film fingerprint fingerprint scanning fingerprints flash drive flash mob Florida flying car food Food Service football ford forensics fossil fuels fountain Foursquare fourth of july fraud Front Street fujifilm Full-body scan fusion future g20 gabrielle giffords Galaxy 15 Galaxy S5 Games gaming Garmin GaussianFace geminoid-dk gender genetics George Lucas geo-tagging Germany gesture control gigapixel gizmodo glasses global infrastructure Global Warming GMS Goggles Google google glass google maps Google Places GPS Grenoble groceries Guinness Gulf Coast oil spill Hackers halloween Hamilton Hannes Harms Harvard HD cameras health healthcare Heart rate Helium helmut Herta Security high resolution high-def camera high-speed cameras high-tech glasses Hilary Clinton Hiroshi Ishiguro history Hitachi holiday travel hologram Home Depot homeland security Honda horses hospital hotels house bills housewives Hoyos Hugh Hefner hulu Human torpedo Humans humor hurricane ibm ice cream iceland icepics ID ID cards ID theft IEDs IHF iID cards Iimage recognition IKEA illusion image recognition imaging Immersion Imperva IMS Research In Orbit inflight entertainment inFORM infrared infrared camera innovation Instagram Intel intelligent intelligent search InteraXon International Space Station Internet in-vehicle camera investigation iOS 5 IP iPad iPads iPhone iphone 5 iPhoto ipod Iran iris scans ISIS ISS it security iTunes Janet Napolitano Japan Jedi Mind Jeopardy Jesse Ventura Jet Blue JetBlue JFK JFK airport John Mica john pistole joke Julian Assange Julian Melchiorri Justin Kevin Costner K-Glass kids Kinect kiss controller kitchen knife Korea korea advanced institute science technology KTH Royal Institute of Technology la guardia language laptop large hadron collider Las Vegas Lasers Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory layar lecture LEGO lens Leon lg library license plates lie detector lifeguard lifelogging light field Lingodroids liquids Locacino location tracking location-based services LoJack london Loop Current Love LPR luggage screening Lumibots lytro machine-learning magic MakerBot malaysia airlines mall Manchester police manmade leaf Mapping Marco Tempest Marijuana Mark Bao mark zuckerberg market growth mars mars500 masks McDonalds Media Lab medical Megapixel Menlo mental fatigue menu menus mercedes messages metamaterials meteor methane Michael Scott Mickey Nilsson microscope Microsoft middle east Military millimeter wave technology mind control Mind reading MindMeld Minnesota Minority Report Mirage Hotel missing MIT Mixed Reality Labs Mobile mobile phones Mobotix modest molecular sensor Monarch moon morality moscow Motion Capture motion detection Movie MovieReshape mug shots museum museum security Music Nao NASA National Geographic national ID cards Navy net Netherlands network cameras NeuroSky MindSet night vision North Korea Novel NPR NTT Docomo nudity NutriSmart nutrition management NYU Oasis Obama Object Recognition object tracking Oculus Rift odor office oil water separator OLED olympics omni-focused video cameras On the Wings of Innovation online online dating Ontario Aerospace Council Open-source Software Opt-In oragami robots Orbital Technologies osama bin laden Oxford palm passwords patdown pat-down patient PayPal Penn Vet Working Dog Center perimeter Personal Mobility Pets phone call photo sharing Photobomb Photography Photoshop Photosynth photosynthesis Picasa pilot Pioneer Pistole pizza plane plants plastic waste Playboy Playport pod police pPrivacy PR2 predator printing prism skylabs prison prius Privacy private security Privates professors projection prosthetic arm Protei Puffersphere punch pupil pyramids QR code quadcopter quantum cryptography Queen's University R2 radar radio radioactive materials detection rail station Rajiv Shah Raytheon realitypod receptionist reducing accidents reflections remote workers remotely piloted aircraft Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute restaurants Retail Review reviews Reza Baruni RFID rhinos Richardson riots RNCOS Robocop robot Robot Soccer robotic sub Robotics Robots Rocky Mountain Arsenal National Wildlife Refuge Royal College of Art RPI Russell Miller Russia ryuma niiyama Safety Samsung San Francisco SAR satellites saudi arabia Sauron save lives SBI scanner SceneTap Scentee scents school Science scientific research sci-fi SCIO Scorpion screening sea lions seamless Search Seaswarm Secret Service Secure Flight Security security cameras Security Industry Association see-through devices self folds self-driving car self-healing self-portrait send to sync sensor Sensors sept. 11 sex offender registry shame shape recognition share happy shazam sheep Sheldon shoe bombs shopping signage Silk Leaf singularity skin sky skype sleep slow motion Smart AR smart baby monitor Smart Cameras smart cars Smart Fence smart homes smart phones smart sensors smart TV smartphone smartphones SmartPlate Smartpones smell smells soccer Social media software solar panels solar system Sony sound South Africa South Korea Southwest Airlines Space space camera Space exploration space hotel space travel Spaceport America Runway SpaceX spectrometer speech recognition speed of light Spinnaker spy spy camera spy plane Star Wars statue stem-cell stephen colbert Steve Furber steve jobs stitching stop-motion street tag Street View students submarine supreme court surgeons surgery Surveillance suspect arrested sxsw Synthetic brain tablets tactile device teacher technology teen telecommuting Telenoid R1 terradynamics Terrorism terrrorist text text messaging texts Thanksgiving the bear The Office thermal camera thief thirsty thought-controlled entertainment Tilt-shift photography Times Square Tissot T-Mobile Tokyo Game Show Tomas Saraceno TomTom top 1 Toray Toshiba touchscreen trace explosive detectors tracking traffic safety training Transformer X translate travel TSA t-shirt tsunami Tufts tumeric turns TV Twitter UAVs ubr-1 UC Berkeley UC Davis UC San Diego UCLA UH-60M Black Hawk UK university university of arizona University of Manchester University of Pennsylvania University of Texas University of Washington Unlogo unmanned Unmanned Aerial Vehicles US Navy usa today USC vascular pattern recognition vein vending machine verizon video video cameras video games video surveillance viewdle violence virgin galactic virginia tech virtual boyfriends virtual reality Virtual Space Station visual intelligence Visual search visually impaired voice recognition voicemail VOIP volcano VR Hyperspace VTT walk walks walkthrough bomb detectors Walmart Washington University School of Medicine water supply Watson weapons wearable technology wedding Western Interactive whiskey Wii remote WikiLeaks wildlife Willow Garage windows 8 windshield wine wireless headset wireless security Withings Word Lens World Cup world's tallest building Xbox Xiaoou Tang XM25 x-ray yapp zen bound 2 zero-g zettabyte Zombie Satellite
« Retail Crime Increases in 2009, According to Recent NRF Study | Main | 3D Chip Company Creates Gesture Video Interface »

Sitting Down with Rob Jenkins

I recently connected with Rob Jenkins, a lecturer at the University at Glasgow and leading authority of facial recognition technology in the UK, to pick his brain about different topics in facial recognition, namely airport security, the future of biometric technology and privacy/related concerns.

Rob had some very insightful, innovative answers to my questions, and I'm excited to share them with the growing IHF readership. Going forward, I'm hoping to have other thought leaders and readers contribute content and commentary to this blog, as I'd like to make this more of a forum for biometric, facial recognition and other technology discussions rather than a one-sided conversation. Feel free to make comments on any of the responses or questions, and I will be sure to address them!

Also, check out Rob's departmental Web site for selected publications on gaze perception and other facial identification topics. Very interesting stuff.

In response to Manchester Airport lowering their matching thresholds, The Telegraph quoted you saying that lowering the passport match level to 30 percent would make the system almost worthless. Another perspective is that the previous levels were causing horrendous queues and customer dissatisfaction. Is there a middle ground here?

There is certainly a middle ground in the sense that we can choose where to strike a balance between rejecting genuine matches and accepting false matches. But reducing either type of error generally increases the other, so it’s a trade-off. There is no ‘sweet spot’ where both types of error are reined in.

Despite the advanced nature of this technology, do you believe that there should still be a human element involved in security checks? If so, do you believe we will ever reach a point where this will no longer be necessary?

The main problem with referring the difficult cases to humans is that humans cannot do the task reliably either - even if we’re trained and experienced. Humans are fantastic at matching familiar faces, but our performance with unfamiliar faces is very poor. If we can somehow incorporate the benefits of familiarity into the technology, then it could be transformed.

Facial recognition technologies are popping up all over -- club entrances, bathroom faucets, online photo services, using cameras in lieu of passwords to access computers -- have they hit the tipping point? Is it only time before we use the technology to unlock our front doors and open our car trunks? What trajectory do you see it taking? Staying in security-based deployments, infiltrating everyday life or a balance between the two?

To some extent I think a tipping point is being ushered in, mostly by people who have something to sell. And it is an idea that some sectors are keen to buy into. So in that sense there is a lot of good will wishing the technology to work. I don’t find the gadget market especially troubling, provided that errors are of relatively little consequence. The real danger is in rushing to large-scale security deployments. For applications such as passport control or forensic face recognition the stakes can be much higher, and we know that the available technology is not yet up to the task.

In the same vein, has facial recognition reached a point where accuracy and reliability now line up with the media's expectations?

In my experience, identification errors tend not to go down well with the public. I often ask audiences how often they would be prepared to be the subject of a misidentification. The answers are in the order of once a decade, even when the imagined consequences are minor. That’s a tall order, given the number of identity checks that some proposals entail. It comes as something of a shock when these demands are compared against current capability. As far as media expectations are concerned, I think there has been a change in tone. Traditionally, the emphasis has been on the implications face recognition for privacy, with the unspoken assumption that it is reliable. These days there is more of an awareness that the technology simply is being phased in, whether it works or not. That changes the focus of the debate.

The "Big Brother" argument -- that citizens are losing their individual privacy rights due to increased public security efforts -- is always present in a discussion about surveillance. Is there a point at which facial recognition and biometric technology infringe on personal freedoms and the right to privacy? Is blurring faces enough? Are there places where surveillance should not be allowed?

I don’t think facial recognition and biometric technology necessarily infringe on privacy. It is certainly possible to imagine applications where privacy concerns don’t arise. However, for the security and surveillance applications that have been at the forefront of public discussion, the tension with privacy is fundamental. The whole purpose of identifying someone is to connect them with some other information, and the nature of that information is a major issue. We can think of face recognition as a key to identity. But focusing on the key tends to distract us from other questions, like What’s behind the lock? As more and more information is stored behind the lock, the reliability of the key becomes increasingly important. As does the question of who has access to the key.

The practice of blurring or pixellating faces to protect identity (as in Google Streetview) is often poorly informed. Although such manipulations can make it more difficult for observers to identify people, this is only the case when the observer is unfamiliar with the faces concerned. When the observer is familiar with the face, blurring or pixellating the image does surprisingly little to impede identification.

People have very different ideas about where surveillance should be allowed, and which places should be out of bounds. I don’t really foresee any wide agreement on the extent of coverage that is desirable or acceptable. The general trend is for rapid expansion, especially in the US and the UK, but my impression is that this trend is not driven by public demand.

The UK has over 4 million cameras -- that's one for every 14 people in the country and 200,000 in London alone. Chicago is working to improve its 'Virtual Shield' and include the entire metropolitan area in its surveillance grid to cut down crime. Yet, criminals still often get away with murder -- literally. Are expectations set too high? Are surveillance grids more of a scare tactic in preventing crime from happening rather than proactive in catching criminals in the act?

It has been known for some time that the unprecedented CCTV coverage in the UK has had little or no effect on crime rates. A recent Home Office report revealed that only 3% of crimes were solved using CCTV footage, and suggests that simple improvements to street lighting would be more effective. Part of the problem is that it is unrealistic for police to monitor CCTV footage on the scale that it is produced. But more importantly, little thought has gone into the use of CCTV evidence in court. It has only recently become clear how poor humans are at matching unfamiliar faces, even when the images are far higher quality than could be obtained from CCTV. We’ve already looked at machine performance in this context. Establishing a match that will stand up in court is very difficult indeed.

The deterrent argument is interesting because the figures imply little or no deterrent value in CCTV. The standard explanation for this is that people assume the cameras are not working, which is a reasonable inference to make if they are not reducing crime. However, I wonder if there is also a paradoxical effect of increasing coverage. After all, the more cameras there are, the less likely it is that any particular camera is being monitored.

Reader Comments (31)

thx for all these useful info ,will be happy to read more about this soon !

Just write like you’re talking to your friends. And soon, they will be.

May 26, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterSekisui House

Howdy there,this is Darrel Toliver,just observed your Post on google and i must say this blog is great.may I quote some of the article found in this site to my local friends?i'm not sure and what you think?anyway,Thank you!

May 28, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterDarrel Toliver

I totally love your blog! Thank you for the post, very informative. wty1d8

May 29, 2010 | Unregistered Commentersatellite tv on pc

Great job!

May 29, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterNursing School

Splendid article . Will definitely copy it to my blog,surely with author link pointing towards you..Thanks.

May 29, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterSeo professional

Great post!

May 30, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterNursing Online

Wonderful journey and experience.

June 1, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterTom and jerry games

Intimately, the post is in reality the freshest topic on this registry related issue. I concur with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your forthcoming updates. Saying thanks will not just be enough, for the wonderful clarity in your writing. I will immediately grab your rss feed to stay abreast of any updates.

June 2, 2010 | Unregistered Commenteranti aging clinics

Wonderful journey and experience.

June 2, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterOracle ERP

Nice Website. You should think more about RSS Feeds as a traffic source. They bring me a nice bit of traffic.

June 3, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterIra Cutter

It is nice to see you posting on this topic, I should book mark this website. Just keep up the good work.

June 3, 2010 | Unregistered Commentermobilya modelleri

i cant beleive i stumbled onto your post..thanks so much!!! i am going to have to sign up 2 ur RSS feed so i can keep updated with your post...thanks Again

June 4, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterTyson F. Gautreaux

I’d love to see a follow up on this.

June 4, 2010 | Unregistered Commenteryemek tarifleri

well done!nice job!

June 4, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterEzequiel Markovich

Great post. Looking forward to seeing you write more articles about this subject.

June 5, 2010 | Unregistered Commenterpuffball

hello!, thanks for the info, this post was really nice.

Thanks for sharing the information. I found the info incredibly helpful.

Hello, great article!! I got you bookmarked. Thanks and best wishes

June 6, 2010 | Unregistered Commentercheap insurance

Howdy, your site is on air in the radio! Good job mate. Your posts are truly great and bookmarked. Regards

June 6, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterLoni Lieberg

Simple and effective, great work.

June 6, 2010 | Unregistered Commenternintendo wii

Hey very nice blog!! Man .. Beautiful .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your blog and take the feeds also...

June 6, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterLuis Juares

I have to state, you chose your words well. The ideas you wrote on your encounters are well placed. This is an incredible blog!

June 6, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterMarti Boyken

Thanks for posting, I’ll definitely be subscribing to your blog.

June 6, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterCarroll B. Merriman

Nice website! Keep it up!

June 7, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterWeb Supernatural

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>